More wisdom from Hayek

More from Chapter 1 of the too-little-read masterpiece, The Constitution of Liberty:

“It is often objected that our concept of liberty is merely negative. This is true in the sense that peace is also a negative concept or that security or quiet or the absence of any particular impediment or evil is negative. It is to this class of concepts that liberty belongs: it describes the absence of a particular obstacle—coercion by other men. It becomes positive only through what we make of it. It does not assure us of any particular opportunities, but leaves it to us to decide what use we shall make of the circumstances in which we find ourselves.

But while the uses of liberty are many, liberty is one. Liberties appear only when liberty is lacking: they are the special privileges and exemptions that groups and individuals may acquire while the rest are more or less unfree. Historically, the path to liberty has led through the achievement of particular liberties. But that one should be allowed to do specific things is not liberty, though it may be called “a liberty”; and while liberty is compatible with not being allowed to do specific things, it does not exist if one needs permission for most of what one can do. The difference between liberty and liberties is that which exists between a condition in which all is permitted that is not prohibited by general rules and one in which all is prohibited that is not explicitly permitted.”

Our collective impatience for the alleviation of some social ill is too often capitalized upon by government, which directs that impatience into a distrust of the seemingly slow-working forces of the market, and molds a voting block large enough to procure greater power to intervene, and therefore hamper, the forces at work within a market.  But before we give in to an impatience-turned-politicized-outrage, we should remember that only through the elimination of coercion within society will everyone be fed, clothed, housed, and living a life not constantly threatened by famine, disease, or war.  Only nations that attempt to eliminate market forces will you find authoritarian governments, bread lines, starvation, disease, and mass death.

03/27/18 Overnight Links

Hayek on the proper meaning of “liberty”

From chapter 1 of his book, The Constitution of Liberty:

“This confusion of liberty as power with liberty in its original meaning inevitably leads to the identification of liberty with wealth; and this makes it possible to exploit all the appeal which the word “liberty” carries in the support for a demand for the redistribution of wealth. Yet, though freedom and wealth are both good things which most of us desire and though we often need both to obtain what we wish, they still remain different. Whether or not I am my own master and can follow my own choice and whether the possibilities from which I must choose are many or few are two entirely different questions. The courtier living in the lap of luxury but at the beck and call of his prince may be much less free than a poor peasant or artisan, less able to live his own life and to choose his own opportunities for usefulness. Similarly, the general in charge of an army or the director of a large construction project may wield enormous powers which in some respects may be quite uncontrollable, and yet may well be less free, more liable to have to change all his intentions and plans at a word from a superior, less able to change his own life or to decide what to him is most important, than the poorest farmer or shepherd.”

Our ability to choose with whom we wish to interact, the range of voluntary interactions we are free to engage in without threat of arrest and imprisonment, the degree to which our voluntary interactions are protected by the legal system, are the true hallmarks of liberty.  Liberty is the shield that prevents others from wielding power over us, and that in itself is the only virtuous incarnation of power, that used in self-defense.

03/26/18 Links

03/26/18 Morning Links

Weekend Links Vol. 2

03/24/18 Weekend Links

Probably should keep this story posted every day now: Google’s new, $300 million fight against news it doesn’t like

Motherboard: State Department seemingly buys $15,000 iPhone-cracking tech GrayKey

Washington Times: Report: Police routinely using dead people’s fingerprints to unlock iPhones

Salt Lake Tribune: As YouTube bans firearms demonstrations, Utah firm launching its own pro-gun video platform

Reason: Obama harvested data from Facebook and bragged about it.  Why are we only freaking out about it now?

The Guardian: Seven days that shattered Facebook’s facade

Borneo Bulletin: ‘To prison for singing?”: Spanish rappers to serve time for their lyrics

Quartz: China’s censorship body keeps ruining fun on the internet

SHELDON RICHMAN: The Iraq War after 15 years: “Now we mark the 15th anniversary of a foreign-policy decision that rivals Woodrow Wilson’s entry into World War I in its recklessness and cruelty — yet a proper assessment of the atrocity perpetrated by the George W. Bush presidency, aided and abetted by the most prestigious newspapers and television networks in the land, is as elusive as ever. If anything, things have regressed. In an eagerness to paint Trump as the most evil person who has ever lived, many pundits, including Democrats, have found it expedient to look with favor on the execrable Mr. Bush despite the chain of disasters he set in motion in March 2003. As readers well know, my respect for Trump is at far less than zero, but I don’t think anyone looks good merely by comparison to him. Trump may end up doing something worse than Bush’s invasion of Iraq — here’s one reason why — but he hasn’t so far. Trump is bad, but that is no reason to blur history. All that does is help people forget Bush’s many victims.”

Important- FEE: Why one economist abhors Earth Hour

Cato: Small marijuana growers squeezed out by the regulation that follows legalization

National Review: Sociologist claims veganism is connected to ‘White Masculinity’

03/24/18 Morning Links

03/23/18 Links

03/23/18 Overnight Links